diff --git a/DEVELOPMENT.md b/DEVELOPMENT.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..f5d88dd --- /dev/null +++ b/DEVELOPMENT.md @@ -0,0 +1,111 @@ +# WP Allstars Plugin Development Workflow + +This document outlines the development workflow for the WP Allstars Plugin to ensure stable and reliable feature implementation. + +## Development Principles + +1. **Stability First**: The primary goal is maintaining a stable plugin that works reliably +2. **Incremental Changes**: Implement changes in small, manageable increments +3. **Complete Testing**: Every change must be thoroughly tested before integration +4. **Documentation**: All features and changes must be well-documented + +## Branch Structure + +- `main` - Production-ready code, always stable +- `v0.2.3-stable` - Our current stable development branch +- `feature/v0.2.3-stable/{feature-name}` - Feature branches for new development + +## Development Workflow + +### 1. Feature Planning + +1. Identify a feature from the ROADMAP.md file to implement +2. Review any existing implementation in unstable versions +3. Document the implementation plan in ROADMAP.md +4. Create a new feature branch from the stable base + +```bash +git checkout v0.2.3-stable +git checkout -b feature/v0.2.3-stable/sync-guard +``` + +### 2. Feature Implementation + +1. Start with the smallest possible functional change +2. Commit frequently with descriptive commit messages including stability classification +3. Example commit message format: + ``` + [EXPERIMENTAL] Add basic sync guard detection functionality + + - Adds file existence check for .syncing flag + - Implements conditional loading based on flag + - Does not yet handle admin notices + ``` + +4. Reference the ROADMAP.md and TESTING.md documents while implementing + +### 3. Testing + +1. Complete all relevant tests from TESTING.md +2. Add feature-specific tests if needed +3. Test in a clean WordPress environment +4. Test with WP_DEBUG enabled +5. Document any issues found and fix them + +### 4. Code Review + +1. Self-review code for: + - PHP best practices + - WordPress coding standards + - Security considerations + - Performance implications + - Error handling + +2. Consider peer review if possible + +### 5. Integration + +1. Create a pull request to merge into the stable branch +2. Summarize changes, testing performed, and any caveats +3. Once approved, merge using `--no-ff` to preserve feature history + +```bash +git checkout v0.2.3-stable +git merge --no-ff feature/v0.2.3-stable/sync-guard +``` + +4. Tag new version if appropriate: + +```bash +git tag v0.2.3.1-stable +git push origin v0.2.3.1-stable +``` + +5. Update STABILITY.md with the new version information + +### 6. Post-Integration + +1. Deploy to test environment and confirm functionality +2. Update ROADMAP.md to reflect the implemented feature +3. Clean up feature branch if no longer needed + +## Handling Unstable Code References + +When examining code from unstable versions: + +1. **Never copy-paste directly** - Understand the approach and reimplement +2. **Isolate problematic code** - Identify why it might have failed +3. **Take the best ideas** - Implement the concept, not the exact implementation +4. **Document the reference** - Note which version inspired each implementation + +## Versioning Scheme + +- `vX.Y.Z` - Major.Minor.Patch +- `vX.Y.Z-stable` - Stable development branches +- `vX.Y.Z.N-stable` - Minor updates to stable branches + +## Continuous Improvement + +- Regularly review and update these development procedures +- Document lessons learned +- Improve testing procedures based on discoveries \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/ROADMAP.md b/ROADMAP.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..127477a --- /dev/null +++ b/ROADMAP.md @@ -0,0 +1,51 @@ +# WP Allstars Plugin Development Roadmap + +This document outlines features from later versions that we plan to integrate into our stable development branch. The goal is to incrementally implement these features in a stable manner, without introducing critical errors. + +## Feature Backlog + +| Feature | Source Version | Priority | Complexity | Risk | Status | +|---------|----------------|----------|------------|------|--------| +| Multisite Category | v0.2.6 | High | Low | Low | ✅ Implemented in v0.2.3-stable | +| Sync Guard | v0.2.6-fix | High | Low | Low | 🔄 To be implemented | +| More Robust File Loading | v0.2.6-fix | High | Low | Low | ✅ Implemented in v0.2.3-stable | +| Enhanced Admin UI | v0.2.4+ | Medium | Medium | Medium | 🔄 To be implemented | +| Plugin Dashboard | v0.2.6-fix | Medium | Medium | Medium | 🔄 To be implemented | +| New Category Pages | v0.2.4+ | Medium | Low | Low | 🔄 To be implemented | + +## Implementation Strategy + +### Multisite Category with Network Plugin Auditor +- **Description**: Add a "Multisite" filter after Advanced and include network-plugin-auditor +- **Why it failed before**: Didn't properly update all required files for the feature +- **Implementation plan**: Add to free-plugins.php and update class-free-plugins-manager.php to display the category correctly +- **Testing criteria**: Verify category appears in UI and plugin can be installed + +### Sync Guard +- **Description**: Prevent plugin loading during rsync operations to avoid partial file loading +- **Why it failed before**: Added to wrong location, dependent on missing files +- **Implementation plan**: + 1. Create a simpler version of the sync guard + 2. Update post-commit hook to handle sync operations better + 3. Use file flag to signal when sync is in progress +- **Testing criteria**: Verify plugin doesn't attempt to load during sync operations + +### Enhanced Admin UI +- **Description**: Improve the admin interface with better styling and more intuitive navigation +- **Why it failed before**: Too many changes at once without proper testing +- **Implementation plan**: + 1. Small, incremental UI improvements + 2. Focus on one component at a time + 3. Thorough testing after each change +- **Testing criteria**: UI changes shouldn't affect functionality, should be responsive + +## Development Order + +The suggested implementation order is: + +1. Sync Guard +2. Enhanced Admin UI (component by component) +3. Plugin Dashboard improvements +4. New Category Pages + +Each feature should be developed in its own branch and only merged after thorough testing. \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/STABILITY.md b/STABILITY.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..9110d5e --- /dev/null +++ b/STABILITY.md @@ -0,0 +1,32 @@ +# WP Allstars Plugin Stability Status + +This document tracks the stability status of different versions of the WP Allstars Plugin. + +## Stability Classification + +- **[STABLE]**: Thoroughly tested, works as expected in production environments +- **[FUNCTIONAL]**: Works but may have minor issues or incomplete features +- **[EXPERIMENTAL]**: Contains new features that are not fully tested +- **[UNSTABLE]**: Known to have critical issues that affect functionality + +## Version Status + +| Version | Status | Notes | +|---------|--------|-------| +| v0.2.3-stable-base | **[STABLE]** | Base stable version with robust file loading. All core functionality works properly. | +| v0.2.4 | **[UNSTABLE]** | Contains critical errors - reference only for feature ideas. | +| v0.2.6 | **[UNSTABLE]** | Contains file structure issues and critical errors - reference only for feature ideas. | +| v0.2.6-fix | **[UNSTABLE]** | Attempted fixes but still has issues - reference only. | +| v0.2.6-revert | **[UNSTABLE]** | Failed attempt to revert to stable version - do not use. | + +## Current Development + +Current development is based on the v0.2.3-stable-base version. Features from later versions are being analyzed and reimplemented in a stable manner. + +## Stability Guidelines + +1. All new features must be developed in isolated feature branches +2. Comprehensive testing is required before merging +3. Each feature should be implemented as a series of small, atomic commits +4. All commits should include a stability classification in commit messages: [STABLE], [FUNCTIONAL], etc. +5. Full testing checklist must be completed before marking a version as [STABLE] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/TESTING.md b/TESTING.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..98224d9 --- /dev/null +++ b/TESTING.md @@ -0,0 +1,70 @@ +# WP Allstars Plugin Testing Procedures + +This document outlines the testing procedures for the WP Allstars Plugin to ensure stability and reliability. + +## Pre-Merge Testing Checklist + +### Basic Functionality Tests + +- [ ] Plugin activates without errors +- [ ] Plugin deactivates without errors +- [ ] Admin menu appears correctly +- [ ] All submenu items load without errors +- [ ] Settings can be saved without errors +- [ ] Plugin works with WordPress debug mode enabled + +### Feature-Specific Tests + +Each new feature should have its own testing checklist added here. + +#### Multisite Category Feature + +- [ ] "Multisite" category appears in the correct location in the UI +- [ ] Network Plugin Auditor appears in the Multisite category +- [ ] Category filter works when clicked +- [ ] Plugin can be installed from the category + +#### Sync Guard Feature + +- [ ] Plugin doesn't load when .syncing file is present +- [ ] .syncing file is created during sync operations +- [ ] .syncing file is removed after sync completes +- [ ] User is notified when plugin is in sync mode + +### Compatibility Tests + +- [ ] Plugin works with latest WordPress version +- [ ] Plugin works with PHP 7.4+ +- [ ] Plugin works with common themes (Twenty Twenty-Three, Kadence) +- [ ] Plugin co-exists with other popular plugins without conflicts + +### Browser Compatibility + +- [ ] UI works correctly in Chrome +- [ ] UI works correctly in Firefox +- [ ] UI works correctly in Safari +- [ ] UI works correctly in Edge + +### Mobile Responsiveness + +- [ ] Admin interface is usable on mobile devices +- [ ] No layout issues on small screens + +## Testing Process + +1. Create a clean WordPress installation for testing +2. Install and activate the plugin +3. Enable WordPress debug mode (WP_DEBUG = true) +4. Complete all tests in the checklist +5. Document any issues found +6. Fix issues and retest +7. Only mark as [STABLE] when all tests pass + +## Continuous Integration + +For future implementation: + +- [ ] Automated unit tests +- [ ] Integration tests +- [ ] End-to-end tests +- [ ] Code quality checks \ No newline at end of file